The 1904 Anthropology Days and Olympic Games

Sport, Race, and American Imperialism

Edited by Susan Brownell

Critical Studies in the History of Anthropology Series

490 pages
27 photos, 1 figure, 1 map, 2 tables

Hardcover

December 2008

978-0-8032-1098-1

$55.00 Add to Cart

eBook (PDF)

(Requires Adobe Digital Editions)

December 2008

978-0-8032-1909-0

$55.00 Add to Cart

about author bio praise table of contents media awards

About the Book

One of the more problematic sport spectacles in American history took place at the 1904 World’s Fair in St. Louis, which included the third modern Olympic Games. Associated with the Games was a curious event known as Anthropology Days organized by William J. McGee and James Sullivan, at that time the leading figures in American anthropology and sports, respectively. McGee recruited Natives who were participating in the fair’s ethnic displays to compete in sports events, with the “scientific” goal of measuring the physical prowess of “savages” as compared with “civilized men.” This interdisciplinary collection of essays assesses the ideas about race, imperialism, and Western civilization manifested in the 1904 World’s Fair and Olympic Games and shows how they are still relevant.

A turning point in both the history of the Olympics and the development of modern anthropology, these games expressed the conflict between the Old World emphasis on culture and New World emphasis on utilitarianism. Marked by Franz Boas’s paper at the Scientific Congress, the events in St. Louis witnessed the beginning of the shift in anthropological research from nineteenth-century evolutionary racial models to the cultural relativist paradigm that is now a cornerstone of modern American anthropology. Racist pseudoscience nonetheless reappears to this day in the realm of sports.

Author Bio

Susan Brownell is a professor and chair of the Department of Anthropology at the University of Missouri, St. Louis. She is the author of Training the Body for China: Sports in the Moral Order of the People’s Republic and Beijing’s Games: What the Olympics Mean to China.

Contributors: John Bale, Susan Brownell, Mark Dyreson, Henning Eichberg, Gerald R. Gems, Alexander Kitroeff, Suzuko Mousel Knott, Jonathan Marks, Christine M. O’Bonsawin, Nancy J. Parezo, Linda Peavy, Otto J. Schantz, and Ursula Smith.

Praise

"In this edited volume, sports anthropologist Brownell leads an exploration of a forgotten moment in premodern anthropology. . . . A very successful project of intellectual history."—J. Marks, CHOICE

"The multidisciplinary approach offered by this collection succeeds in exposing the relationships between anthropology, physical culture, the Olympic movement, and imperialism in revelatory ways."—John W. Troutman, Western Historical Quarterly

"The authors provide not only a window into the history of a sporting event but also an important story about sports as a system of representation. This volume is a fine collection that recalls a past event that is still relevant to the present."—John Bloom, American Historical Review

"Through their analyses of the 1904 Games, the authors convincingly interrogate—and connect—categories of science, sport, race, and nation at the turn of the 20th century. . . . The book will appeal to a number of audiences, including scholars interested in the histories of anthropology, museums as well as world's fairs and other forms of display, science, sport, colonialism, imperialism, and national and international movements."—Andi Johnson, Museum Anthropology Review

"This is a well-conceived volume that will be of wide interest to many scholars."—Barbara Keys, Journal of American Ethnic History

"The connection between the histories of the Olympics and anthropology provides a unique perspective on the history of sport. . . . The 1904 Anthropology Days and Olympic Games would make an excellent addition to the library of any scholar interested in the history of the Olympics or the history of anthropology."—Colleen English, International Journal of the History of Sports

Introduction: Bodies before Boas, Sport before the Laughter Left (Susan Brownell)

1. A “Special Olympics”: Testing Racial Strength and Endurance at the 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition (Nancy J. Parezo)

2. The “Physical Value” of Races and Nations: Anthropology and Athletics at the Louisiana Purchase Exposition (Mark Dyreson)

3. Pierre de Coubertin’s Concepts of Race, Nation, and Civilization (Otto J. Schantz)

4. Anthropology Days, the Construction of Whiteness and American Imperialism in the Philippines (Gerald R. Gems)

5. “From Savagery to Civic Organization”: The Non-Participation of Canadian “Indians” in the “Anthropology Days” of the 1904 St. Louis Olympic Games (Christine M. O’Bonsawin)

6. “Leav[ing] the White[s] . . . Far Behind Them”: The Girls from Fort Shaw (Montana) Indian School, Basketball Champions of the 1904 World’s Fair (Linda Peavy and Ursula Smith)

7. Germans and Others at the “American Games”: Problems of National and International Representation at the 1904 Olympics (Suzuko Mousel Knott)

8. Greece and the 1904 “American” Olympics (Alexander Kitroeff)

9. From the Anthropology Days to the Anthropological Olympics (John Bale)

10. Olympic Anthropology Days and the Progress of Exclusion: Towards an Anthropology of Democracy (Henning Eichberg)

11. The Growth of Scientific Standards from “Anthropology Days” to Present Days (Jonathan Marks)

Afterword: Back to the Future (Susan Brownell)

Awards

Winner of the 2009 North American Society for Sport History (NASSH) Anthology Award in Sport History

The 1904 Anthropology Days and Olympic Games

Sport, Race, and American Imperialism

About the Book

Author Bio

Praise

Table of Contents

Awards

Also of Interest

A Maverick Boasian

Segregation Made Them Neighbors

Franz Boas

History of Theory and Method in Anthropology

The History of Anthropology

Cree and Christian

Russian Colonization of Alaska

Amazonian Kichwa of the Curaray River

Come Now, Let Us Argue It Out

Writing Anthropologists, Sounding Primitives