"It often takes a great work to plainly state what historians know but rarely say outright. Apostles of Empire is such a book."—Nicholas Lewis, Sixteenth Century Journal
"If this book is any indication, McShea will be an authoritative figure in colonial French history for many years to come. Her ability to extrapolate a nuanced, multifaceted, and unique interpretation from the multivolume Relations is a Herculean task for any scholar in this field. However, her true skill comes from understanding the context and, even at times, subtext of the primary sources."—William Carroll, H-Borderlands
"[Apostles of Empire] represents a valuable contribution to French colonial history and transatlantic cultural and intellectual exchange, as well as to a better understanding of French influence on the development of modern American society in general."—Mirela Altic, Terrae Incognitae
"Apostles of Empire is an excellent transatlantic history of the French Jesuit order that problematizes the historiographical divide between missionary work and empire."—Eric J. Toups, Connections. A Journal for Historians and Area Specialists
"McShea's book is an impressive work of research, one which adds considerably to our knowledge of the mission of the Society of Jesus in North America."—Michael Walsh, Reading Religion
“One comes away from the book with a sense of a lost world recovered and portrayed in loving detail. McShea has done for early modern North America and New France what Andrew Willard Jones’s Before Church and State did for the France of the thirteenth century. The result is a triumph of the historian’s art.”—Adrian Vermeule, America: The Jesuit Review
"This text firmly establishes McShea as a leading contemporary scholar of French religious history. . . . In our time of resurgent national feeling throughout the West and much intra-Catholic disagreement about the nation's place in the world, the type of realism advocated by McShea in trying to understand what Catholics do, and how and why they do it, seems more necessary than ever."—Samuel Gregg, Catholic World Report
"Apostles of Empire is a meticulously researched, elegantly written, and precisely aimed salvo intended to demolish some of historiography's most cherished myths about the Jesuits in North America."—Mary Dunn, Journal of Jesuit Studies
"McShea’s deeply original monograph is a must read for scholars of Early America. Authoritatively debunking the myth of French Jesuit missions as otherworldly, Apostles of Empire demonstrates that we cannot fully understand the history of North American imperial competition without French Jesuits."—Gabrielle Guillerm, American Catholic Studies
"Apostles of Empire is an important addition to the historiography of Jesuit missions, New France, and the French Atlantic World."—Riley Wallace, Archivum Historicum Societatis Iesu